Past Shows - 1908 to 2006
| 1908 | Trial By Jury | 1948 | Blossom Time | 1982 | Annie Get Your Gun |
| 1909 | Pirates of Penzance | 1949 | Le Cloches de Corneville | Half a Sixpence | |
| 1910 | Dorothy | 1950 | The Maid of the Mountains | 1983 | Oklahoma! |
| The Prince of Tartary | 1951 | Goodnight Vienna | Hello Dolly | ||
| 1911 | Iolanthe | 1952 | Rose Marie | 1984 | The King and I |
| The Gondoliers | 1953 | Virginia | Pickwick | ||
| The Mikado | 1954 | Belle of New York | 1985 | South Pacific | |
| 1912 | Yeoman of the Guard | 1955 | The Lisbon Story | Hans Andersen | |
| Patience | 1956 | Me and My Girl | 1986 | Carousel | |
| 1913 | Merrie England | 1957 | Land of Smiles | Guys and Dolls | |
| Iolanthe | 1958 | The Dancing Years | 1987 | Fiddler on the Roof | |
| 1914 | The Mikado | 1959 | Oklahoma | West Side Story | |
| Dorothy | 1960 | Ali Baba & the 40 Thieves | 1988 | Camelot | |
| 1915 | H.M.S. Pinafore | The Merry Widow | Oliver! | ||
| The Sorcerer | 1961 | Carousel | 1989 | The Pyjama Game | |
| Trial by Jury | 1962 | Brigadoon | My Fair Lady | ||
| The Gondoliers | South Pacific | 1990 | The Sound of Music | ||
| 1919 | The Mikado | 1963 | Free as Air | Seven Brides for | |
| Merrie England | Annie Get Your Gun | Seven Brothers | |||
| 1920 | Tom Jones | 1964 | Wedding in Paris | Show Boat | |
| The Gondoliers | Music Man | 1991 | The Music Man | ||
| 1921 | Les Cloches de Corneville | 1965 | Oklahoma! | The Wizard of Oz | |
| The Chocolate Soldier | Flower Drum Song | 1992 | Brigadoon | ||
| 1922 | The Duchess of Dantzig | 1966 | Carousel | Anything Goes | |
| The Mikado | Call Me Madam | 1993 | The Most Happy Fella | ||
| 1923 | Merrie England | 1967 | Summer Song | Kiss Me Kate | |
| Yeoman of the Guard | Kiss Me Kate | 1994 | Annie Get Your Gun | ||
| 1924 | The Rebel Maid | 1968 | Guys and Dolls | 42nd Street | |
| Dorothy | My Fair Lady | 1995 | Irene | ||
| 1925 | Iolanthe | 1969 | Robert and Elizabeth | VE Day - A Celebration | |
| Les Cloches de Corneville | Half a Sixpence | Half a Sixpence | |||
| 1926 | The Pirates of Penzance | 1970 | How to Succeed In Business | 1996 | Barnum |
| Trial By Jury | Without Really Trying | South Pacific | |||
| Tom Jones | The Most Happy Fella | 1997 | Hello Dolly | ||
| 1927 | Miss Hook of Holland | 1971 | Hello Dolly | Follies | |
| Box and Cox | The Pyjama Game | 1998 | Crazy for You | ||
| H.M.S. Pinafore | 1972 | Camelot | Yankee Doodle Dandy | ||
| 1928 | Katinka | Fiddler on the Roof | 1999 | The Hot Mikado | |
| Madame Pompadour | 1973 | Sweet Charity | Carousel | ||
| 1929 | The Count of Luxembourg | Oliver! | 2000 | Fiddler on the Roof | |
| The Belle of Brittany | 1974 | Anne of Green Gables | Showstoppers | ||
| 1930 | The Geisha | Mame | 2001 | Annie | |
| The Vagabond King | 1975 | Two Gentlemen of Verona | Oklahoma! | ||
| 1931 | Blue Eyes | Calamity Jane | 2002 | Pirates of Penzance | |
| Rose Marie | 1976 | Funny Girl | Annie Get Your Gun | ||
| 1932 | The Desert Song | King's Rhapsody | 2003 | Oliver! | |
| The VagabondKing | 1977 | The Boyfriend | The Wizard of Oz | ||
| 1933 | Song of the Sea | The Dancing Years | 2004 | Guys and Dolls | |
| No, No, Nanette | 1978 | Gigi | Noteability | ||
| 1934 | Virginia | Kiss Me Kate | Me and My Girl | ||
| 1935 | The Maid of the Mountains | 1979 | Brigadoon | 2005 | Curtain Up! |
| 1936 | The Three Musketeers | Irene | Half a Sixpence | ||
| 1937 | The Desert Song | 1980 | Idol Days | 2006 | 42nd Street |
| 1938 | Rose Marie | The Music Man | 2007 | Thoroughly Modern Millie | |
| 1939 | Goodnight Vienna | 1981 | No, No, Nanette | ||
| 1947 | Hit the Deck | Applause |